A-

The second novel in Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy was easily as good as the first. I found The Subtle Knife to be very well written in style meant for children, but that also applies well to adults. The novel has a darker tone than the first in the series. Philosophical and religious ideas challenge the reader, and add controversy and weight to the classic hero story.

The Subtle Knife continues the story of Lyra Silvertongue as she journeys through the opening created by her father, Lord Asriel, into another world. Supporting characters including Serafina Pekkala, Iorek Byrnison, and Lee Scoresby also return with expanded roles. The novel also introduces the new character, Will Parry, into a primary role. Will is really a great character, easy to relate to and one that compliments Lyra very well.

Much like the first, The Subtle Knife was an excellent adventure that embodied the kind of magic that can enthrall children and adults alike. The novel continues to develop the engaging storyline from the first novel along with Lyra’s character. Many of the central themes are expanded upon, increasingly challenging traditional Christian beliefs.

Though the novel was very engaging, it also contains some challenges to many religious beliefs. The novel may not be suitable for all children, though I wouldn’t expect it to actually mold anyone’s beliefs. In the end, the The Subtle Knife is an intelligent and fast-paced fantasy novel that pulls you in and enlightens the imagination.